Case Studies

The Case Studies illustrate examples of patients likely to be encountered in SCI rehabilitation settings and provide an opportunity to integrate one's knowledge of the Rehabilitation Evidence with actual clinical problems. These case-based scenarios can serve as a medium for continuing medical education and are configured in various formats so as to meet the needs of different audiences (specialist and non-specialist clinicians, residents and students) as part of a comprehensive knowledge translation strategy for optimizing care delivery to SCI health care providers.

Level of Injury Outcome Measures Severity of Injury Quizzes By Topic Complete Case List

Case 12: Mrs. AJ

PDF Download: 

Mrs. A.J. is an 84-year-old female with a T3, anterior cord spinal injury (SCI), severity C on the ASIA Impairment scale (AIS).  Mrs. A.J. was in her driveway shoveling snow when she slipped and fell on some ice.  Mrs. A.J. was not able to get up from the ground and was found lying there by a neighbour who was coming home from work and noticed her on the ground.  An ambulance was called.  Initially, it was thought that Mrs. A.J. had most likely fractured her hip until further testing in the ER department confirmed a SCI.  She was found to have a T3, anterior cord spinal injury (SCI), severity of C on the AIS.

 

 

 

Assessing Risk for Developing Pressure Ulcers

Once medically stable, Mrs. A.J. was transferred from neurosurgical unit to the rehabilitation floor.  Mrs. A.J.’s nurse voiced concerned that Mrs. A.J. is at “high risk” of developing a pressure ulcer. 

Understanding the risk factors for developing pressure ulcers.

1.  What are the risk factors for developing pressure ulcers in persons with SCI?

Risk factors that have been identified most often include: limitation in activity and mobility, injury completeness, moisture from bowel and bladder incontinence, lack of sensation, muscle atrophy, poor nutritional status and being underweight. 

 

Figure 1.Common pressure points for wound formation

The above flash video demonstrates self skin check techniques.

"Graphic reproduced with permission of SCI-U (Go to
http://www.spinalcordconnections.ca/Spotlight/Spotlight-Content-1.aspx to
see eLearning modules about SCI)

 

 

Wound care is multi-facetted and the SCI team has an interprofessional approach to the assessment and management of this issue.  As best practice, the team uses a validated and reliable outcome measure for determining pressure ulcer risk. 

Understanding which tools are available to assess for risk pressure ulcer development.

 

2.  Name scales used to assess risk of developing a pressure ulcer?

  1. Braden Scale
  2. Waterlow Scale
  3. Spinal Cord Injury Pressure Ulcer Scale (SCIPUS)

 

The clinical team wants to discuss the merits of these scales as a risk assessment tool.

Understanding the advantages and disadvantages of the Braden Scale, Waterlow Scale and Spinal Cord Injury Pressure Ulcer Scale (SCIPUS).


3. Compare the Braden, Waterlow and Spinal Cord Injury Pressure Ulcer scales.

 

Scale

Items

Advantages

Disadvantages

Braden Scale

 

Patients are evaluated on six domains:

  1. Sensory Perception
  2. Moisture
  3. Activity
  4. Mobility
  5. Nutrition
  6. Friction and shear
  • Available in many languages
  • No respondent burden (the patients is not asked to perform any special activities)
  • Reliability has not been tested on the SCI populations
  • Scale items such as sensory perception, mobility and nutritional variables are not significant variables in  pressure ulcer development in individuals with SCI

Waterlow Scale

 

Patients are evaluated on eight domains:

  1. Age
  2. Sex
  3. Body Build
  4. Appetite
  5. Continence of urine and feces
  6. Mobility
  7. Skin appearance in risk areas
  8. Special risks
  • The scale is quick and easy to use clinically without respondent burden
  • No rationale behind how the score numbers were determined
  • Poor descriptive details in the scale items used
  • Poor inter-rater reliability has been found in other populations, the reliability of this scale has not been tested specifically with the SCI populations
  • The scale did not include items that were found to be significant predictors in pressure ulcer development for people with SCI

Spinal Cord Injury Pressure Ulcer Scale(SCIPUS) Measure

Patients are evaluated on the following domains:

  • Level of activity
  • Mobility
  • Complete SCI
  • Urine incontinence or constantly moist
  • Autonomic dysreflexia or severe spasticity
  • Age
  • Tobacco use/ Smoking
  • Pulmonary Disease
  • Cardiac Disease or glucose > 110 mg/dl
  • Renal disease
  •  Impaired cognitive function
  • Residing in a nursing home or hospital
  •  Albumin < 3.4 or T, protein < 6.4
  • Hematorcrit <36.0%
  • Reported to be the best measure for individual with SCI
  • Since the scale was designed specifically for use in rehabilitations centers, its reliability has not been tested in the community populations
  • Blood tests are required if the patients has not been previously tested for diabetes, albumin and hemocrit

 

 

Pressure Ulcer Prevention

 

 

Mrs. A.J. is considered a very high risk of developing pressure ulcers and would like to know what preventative treatments are available. 

Understanding preventative management of pressure ulcers.

 

1.  What are the recommendations for preventing pressure ulcers in persons with SCI?

Lifelong prevention recommendations include:

  1. Examining skin daily to allow for early detection of a pressure ulcer.
  2. Shifting body weight in bed and wheelchair on a regular basis independently or with assistance.
  3. Keeping moisture accumulation to a minimum and cleaning and drying skin promptly after soiling.
  4. Having an individually prescribed wheelchair, pressure redistribution cushion and power tilt mechanism if manual pressure relief is not possible.
  5. Ensuring all equipment is maintained and functioning properly.
  6. Decreasing or stopping smoking.
  7. Limiting alcohol intake.
  8. Optimize diet and hydration.

Whenever possible, individuals who are at risk for pressure ulcer development or who are being treated for a pressure ulcer should be referred to a registered dietitian for assessment and intervention as necessary

Recommendations for prevention or treatment of a pressure ulcer would include eating a well balanced, nutritionally complete diet with appropriate calories, proteins, micronutrients (vitamins and minerals) and fluids.

 

 

2.  List the different methods studied for preventing pressure ulcers in persons with SCI for which there is evidence.

  1. Electrical Stimulation
  2. Education on Pressure-Relief Techniques
  3. Modifying Seating Parameters
  4. Specialized Seating Clinics
  5. Social Cognitive Approaches with Reward Systems
  6. Telerehabilitation Approaches

 

3.  What is the evidence associated with Electrical Stimulation to prevent pressure ulcers?

There is limited (level 4) evidence that electrical stimulation may prevent pressure ulcers from developing by decreasing ischial pressures and increasing blood flow to tissues, but more research is needed.

Prevention studies are focusing on skin vs. muscle stimulation, dynamic vs. long-term effects and surface vs. implanted devices.  One effect under investigation is the ability of electrical stimulation to change blood flow to skin and muscle.  It is believed that by increasing regional blood flow, tissue health would be enhanced assisting with pressure ulcer prevention.

 

SCIRE found limited (level 4) evidence that electrical stimulation may decrease ischial pressures and increase blood flow to tissues.

 

 

Figure 2. Electrical stimulation set-up for pressure ulcer prevention

For more information, please see: Electrical Stimulation.

 

 

4.  What is the evidence associated with Pressure-Relief Techniques in preventing pressure ulcers?

  1. 65° of tilt or forward leaning of >45° both showed significant reduction in pressure.
  2. The type and duration of pressure relief by position changing must be individualized post SCI using pressure mapping or similar techniques.
  3. More research is needed to see if decreasing ischial pressures and/or increasing blood flow to tissues using weight shifting techniques will help prevent pressure ulcers post SCI. 
  4. For most individuals with SCI, a pushup/vertical lift of 15-30 seconds is unlikely to be sufficient to allow for complete pressure relief.

Teaching individuals with spinal cord injuries to shift their weight regularly while seated is a common and intuitive recommendation for pressure ulcer preventionas it is hypothesized that this relieves pressure on at risk tissues and allows for recovery of blood flow and oxygenation.  Several techniques have been suggested depending on the physical and cognitive status of the individual and include a lateral, forward lean or vertical push upWhen a manual weight shift cannot be performed the use of a power tilt feature has been recommended.

 

SCIRE found level 3 evidence that 1-2 minutes of pressure relief must be sustained to raise tissue oxygen to unloaded levels and level 4 evidence to support position changes to reduce pressure at the ischial sites and that forward flexion is an effective method of pressure relief.

 

 

Figure 3a: Tilt System

 

 

Figure 3b: Pressure Relief technique

Source: Copyright © 2010 by University of Washington/MSKTC

For more information, please see: Pressure Relief Practices.

 

 

5.  What is the evidence associated with Pressure Ulcer Prevention Education Post SCI in preventing pressure ulcers?

  1. Structured pressure ulcer prevention education helps individuals post SCI gain and retain knowledge of pressure ulcer prevention practices. 
  2. Research is needed to determine the specific educational needs of individuals with SCI required to reduce the risk of pressure ulcer formation. 
  3. More research is needed to determine if pressure ulcer prevention education results in a reduction of pressure ulcers post SCI.

Pressure ulcer prevention education programs for individuals with SCI provide knowledge and emphasize behaviours intended to reduce the risk of pressure ulcer occurrence

SCIRE found level 1 evidence that providing enhanced pressure ulcer education and structured follow-up results in a significantly longer time before recurrence of pressure ulcers especially in those individuals with no previous history of pressure ulcer surgery.

Providing enhanced pressure ulcer prevention education is effective at helping individuals with SCI gain and retain this knowledge (Level 4).

For more information, please see: Pressure Ulcer Prevention Education.

 

 

6.   What is the evidence associated with Pressure Modifying Seating Parameters in preventing pressure ulcers?

  1. There is level 3 evidence that various cushions or seating systems (e.g. dynamic versus static) are associated with potentially beneficial reduction in seating interface pressure or pressure ulcer risk factors like skin temperature.
  2. There is level 3 evidence that adding lumbar support to the wheelchair of those with chronic SCI has a negligible effect on reducing seated buttock pressures at the ischial tuberosities. 

Cushion Type
 

47% of pressure ulcers occur at the ischial tuberosities or sacrum and are therefore more likely to have been initiated while seated.  See Figure 4 for areas where bones are close to the surface (called "bony prominences") and areas that are under the most pressure are at greatest risk for developing pressure ulcers.  Provision of a wheelchair cushion that relieves and redistributes pressure and reduces risk of pressure ulcer formation is an important prevention recommendation.  Historically, cushion design has been based on the belief that sitting interface pressure should be distributed evenly to reduce areas of high pressure underneath bony prominences.

 

SCIRE found level 3 evidence that various cushions or seating systems (e.g. dynamic versus static) are associated with potentially beneficial reduction in seating interface pressure or pressure ulcer risk factors like skin temperature. Conclusions from studies state that no one cushion is suitable for all individuals with SCI and cushion selection should be based on a combination of pressure mapping results, clinical knowledge of prescriber, individual characteristics and preference.

Lumbar Support Thickness

The addition of lumbar support to wheelchairs had a minimal effect on reducing highest seated buttock pressure at the ischial tuberosities of subjects with chronic ≥ 3 years SCI.

Figure 4. Areas where bones are close to the surface (called "bony prominences") and areas that are under the most pressure are at greatest risk for developing pressure ulcers.

Source: Copyright © 2010 by University of Washington/MSKTC

For more information, please see: Cushion Selection and Lumbar Support.

 

 

7.   What is the evidence associated with Specialized Seating Clinics in preventing pressure ulcers?

There is Level 2 evidence showing that early attendance at specialized seating assessment clinics (SSA) increases the skin management abilities of individuals post SCI. 

The incorporation of seating clinics into both the inpatient and outpatient rehabilitation program has been shown to reduce the incidence of pressure ulcers and readmission rates due to pressure ulcers

SCIRE found Level 2 evidence that attendance at a Specialized Seating Assessment (SSA) clinic did improve individual’s skin management abilities and that early attendance was optimal.

For more information, please see: Specialized Seating Clinics.

 

8.  What is the evidence associated with Social Cognitive Approaches in preventing pressure ulcers?

There is very limited level 4 evidence to suggest that the introduction of behavioural contingencies (i.e. financial rewards) is associated with a reduction in pressure ulcer severity and decreased health care costs.

SCIRE found limited level 4 evidence indicated when behavioural contingencies (i.e. financial rewards) were introduced, positive behaviours resulted.  For some, participants results were sustainable once behavioural contingencies were withdrawn.

For more information, please see: Behavioural Contingencies.

Telerehabilitation Approaches to Pressure Ulcer Prevention

 

 

8.  What is the evidence associated with Telerehabilitation approaches in preventing pressure ulcers?

 

1.    There is insufficient evidence that telerehabilitation makes a significant difference in the prevention and treatment of pressure ulcers post SCI.  More research is needed into its effectiveness for improving healing and reducing costs.

 

 

SCIRE found insufficient support for the use of telerehabilitation in delivery of cost effective prevention strategies and early pressure ulcer identification and treatment.

For more information, please see: Telerehabilitation.

SCI Specific Care

 

A few months after being discharged, Mrs. A.J. returned to a SCI specific outpatient clinic for a follow up appointment.  She is wondering if she should just go to a general outpatient clinic.

Understanding the importance of SCI specific care at follow-up.

 

26.  What evidence is there to support an SCI-specific intervention approach with individuals with SCI following inpatient rehabilitation? 

Routine visits to SCI-specific outpatient clinics and comprehensive education programs can prevent secondary complications, and facilitate the knowledge and use of community resources.

A major challenge for recently discharged SCI consumers is continuation of specialized care in the community.In general, outpatients are followed up by family physicians or general rehabilitation facilities that do not specialize in SCI.  In addition, the concept of aging with an SCI is a relatively new phenomenon and many facilities are not equipped to adequately manage common secondary complications such as bladder and bowel issues, pressure ulcers, and osteoporosis. Also, in some jurisdictions initial rehabilitation hospital stays have become shorter in recent years. Consequently rehospitalisation following rehabilitation among persons with SCI remains high.

 

There are several proposed models to these dilemmas is the development of outpatient SCI-specific rehabilitation facilities intended to ease the transition between inpatient care and community reintegration. The purpose of these interventions is to prevent secondary complications from occurring such as pressure ulcers and urinary tract infections, as well as to increase knowledge of and access to community resources.

 

SCIRE found level 4 evidence using a non-controlled post-test design that a nurse-led outpatient clinic may be effective in preventing secondary complications of SCI. A case series design that transitional rehabilitation may increase the use of community resources and provide more opportunity to interact with family.  A targeted education program may improve knowledge and acquisition of community resources (Level 4).

Clinical Features of Spasticity

At this appointment, Mrs. A.J. reported that her markedly increased spasticity in both lower extremities has been affecting her ability to transfer.  The physiotherapist is very concerned about Mrs. A.J.’s spasticity and how it is impacting her life. 

Understanding the clinical features and impact of spasticity on people with SCI.

 

1. How is spasticity defined?

The classic definition of spasticity is: "A motor disorder characterized by a velocity dependent increase in tonic stretch reflexes (muscle tone) and increased tendon jerks resulting from disinhibition of the stretch reflex, as one component of an upper motor neuron lesion."

While a more up to date definition states that spasticity is: "disordered sensori-motor control, resulting from an upper motor neuron lesion, presenting as intermittent or sustained involuntary activation of muscle."

 

2.  What are the various clinical features of spasticity?

  1. Velocity dependent increase in tonic stretch reflexes (increased tone)
  2. Increased tendon jerks
  3. Upper motor neuron syndrome
  4. Clonus
  5. Spasms
  6. Hyperreflexia
  7. Hypertonia

 

Figure 1a. Phasic stretch reflex.  This picture shows reflex pathways that may underlie hyperactive phasic stretch reflexes of spasticity. 

 

Figure 1b.  Tonic stretch reflex arc.  This picture shows reflex pathways that may underlie hyperactive tonic stretch reflexes of spasticity.

 

 

Figure 1c.  Cutaneomuscular (flexor withdrawal) reflex.  This picture shows reflex pathways that may underlie the hyperactive cutaneomuscular reflex of spasticity.

Assessing Spasticity

 

This is a teaching hospital and students of all disciplines have clinical placements here.  A rehabilitation therapy student having a placement on the SCI service wants to know how one actually measures spasticity. 

Understanding the various tools used to assess spasticity.


1.  List the most common outcome measures for spasticity used in clinical practice (how are each performed and what is the measurement scale).

The most common outcome measures used in clinical practice include:

  1. Ashworth and Modified Ashworth Measure of Spasticity
  2. Penn Spasm Frequency Scale (PSFS)
  3. Surface electromyography (sEMG)

The Ashworth Measure of Spasticity

A 5-point nominal scale using subjective clinical assessment of tone ranging from 0 – “no increases in tone” to 4 – “limb rigid in flexion or extension [abduction/adduction]”. An additional grade was added (1+) for the Modified Ashworth (MAS) to enhance sensitivity and accommodate hemiplegic patients who typically graded at the lower end of the scale.  Clinical examination is performed on a relaxed supine patient. The muscle is assessed by rating the resistance to passive range of motion (ROM) about a single joint.

The Penn Spasm Frequency Scale (PSFS)

A self report measure of the frequency or reported muscle spasms which is commonly used to quantify spasticity. The PSFS is a 2 component self-report scale developed to augment clinical ratings of spasticity and provide a more comprehensive understanding of an individual’s spasticity status. The first component is a 5 point scale assessing the frequency with which spasms occur ranging from “0 = No spasms” to “4 = Spontaneous spasms occurring more than ten times per hour”. The second component is a 3 point scale assessing the severity of spasms ranging from “1 = Mild” to “3 = Severe”. The second component is not answered if the person indicates they have no spasms in part 1.  Patients report their perceptions of spasticity with regards to frequency and severity.

Surface Electromyography (sEMG)

A noninvasive technique used to measure muscle activity (both voluntary and involuntary) in individuals with neuromuscular diseases  Surface electrodes are placed on the skin overlying the muscles of interest.  Patients are instructed to voluntarily activate lower limb muscles to provide either maximal muscle strength or to perform simple movements (e.g. ankle flexion/extension).  

For more information, please see: Ashworth Measure of Spasticity, Penn Spasm Frequency Scale (PSFS), Surface Electromyography (sEMG).

 

Physical Treatments for Spasticity

 

Mrs. A.J. would like to learn more about how spasticity can be treated and she is adamant about not using medications.  Mrs. A.J. wants to know what interventions are available and whether they are worthwhile in trying.

Understanding available physical treatments for spasticity post SCI.

1.  List physical therapies used in treatment of spasticity.

  1. Rhythmic passive movements
  2. Muscle stretch
  3. Active exercise interventions
  4. Electrical stimulation
  5. Neural Facilitation and Baclofen *(the positive effects of this combination treatment may be due to baclofen alone)
  6. Hippotherapy

Typical clinical approaches to spasticity include rhythmic passive movements, muscle stretch, active exercise interventions, electrical stimulation, and ongoing (TENS) transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation.

In addition different resaerchers have examined other treatment options including: penile vibration and rectal probe stimulation, other forms of afferent stimulation which may not be appropriate for routine clinical practice.

Individuals with severe spasticity may chose to undergo more invase surgical options such as spinal cord stimulation and dorsal longitudinal T-myelotomy.

Self-stretching, regular physiotherapy and physical activities affect spasticity and should be considered as a therapeutic approach prior to antispastic medication and surgical procedures. Therapies based on physical interventions are advantageous as they generally have fewer related adverse events although they also typically have short-lasting effects.

 

 

2.  Provide the evidence for physical therapies used in treatment of spasticity.

  1. Rhythmic passive movements may produce short-term reductions in spasticity.
  2. Prolonged standing or other methods of producing muscle stretch may result in reduced spasticity.
  3. Active exercise interventions such as hydrotherapy and (FES) functional electrical stimulation-assisted walking may produce short-term reductions in spasticity.
  4. Electrical stimulation applied to individual muscles may produce a short term decrease in spasticity.  There is also some concern that long-term use of electrical stimulation may increase spasticity.
  5. Hippotherapy may result in short-term reductions in spasticity.
  6. A combination of neural facilitation techniques and Baclofen may reduce spasticity.

Hydrotherapy and Stretching

Short-term reduction in spasticity may result from hydrotherapy (Level 2), rhythmic, passive movements and externally applied forces or passive muscle stretch (Level 4).

There is no evidence describing the length and time course of the treatment effect related to spasticity for hydrotherapy. 

FES-Assisted Walking

SCIRE foundlevel 4 evidence that a program of FES-assisted walking acts to reduce ankle spasticity in the short-term (i.e., 24 hours).  There is no evidence describing the length and time course of the treatment effect related to spasticity for FES-assisted walking. 

Surface Muscle Stimulation

Single treatment of surface muscle stimulation reduces local muscle spasticity with agonist stimulation more effective than stimulation to the antagonist (Level 2).  There is conflicting evidence for how long the effects of a single treatment of electrical stimulation on muscle spasticity persist, although they appear to be relatively short lasting (i.e., 6 hours).  Based on a single pre-post study, there is no evidence that a long-term program of muscle stimulation has an effect on reducing muscle spasticity and may even increase local muscle spasticity.

Transcutaneous Electrical Nerve Stimulation

TENS, is focused on stimulating large, low threshold afferent nerves so as to alter motor-neuron excitability and thereby reduce spasticity.

SCIRE foundlevel 1 evidence from a single RCT that an ongoing program of TENS acts to reduce spasticity as demonstrated by clinical and electrophysiological measures for up to 24 hours.  A single treatment of TENS acts to reduce spasticity but to a lesser degree than that seen with ongoing programs of TENS. This evidence is muted somewhat by conflicting results with a null result (level 2) compared with 2 positive results (level 4).

Hippotherapy

Physical, occupational and speech therapists use hippotherapy, which uses the movement of the horse, for clients who have movement dysfunction. There is level 2 evidence from a single study supported by level 4 evidence from another studythat hippotherapy may reduce lower limb muscle spasticity immediately following an individual session.

 

Figure 1. Hippotherapy may result in short-term reductions in spasticity.

 

Neurofacilitation Techniques and Baclofen

SCIRE found limited level 1 evidence that a combination of a 6 week course of neural facilitation techniques (Bobath, Rood and Brunnstrom approaches) and Baclofen may reduce lower limb muscle spasticity with a concomitant increase in ADL independence. However, the results of this study should be assessed with caution, since the positive effects may be due to baclofen alone.


For more information, please see: Passive Movement or Stretching, Active Movement, Direct Muscle Electrical Stimulation and Various Forms of Afferent Stimulation.

Quiz: Identifying pressure ulcer risk factors

 

Robert has been assessed as having a severity of B on the AIS and a C6.  He is immobile for long periods of time, has poor nutritional health and is affected by bowel and bladder incontinence.  Which of the following factor (s) are potential risk factors for her developing a pressure ulcer?

 

Male

Male

 

Limited mobility

Limited mobility

 

Severity of Injury

 

Severity of Injury

 

Potential moisture from bowel and bladder incontinence

 

Potential moisture from bowel and bladder incontinence

 

Poor nutritional status

Poor nutritional status

 

All of the above

All of the above

 

 

 

Quiz: Tools to assess pressure ulcers

 

What outcome measure is used to assess the risk of developing a pressure ulcer?

 

1. Braden Scale

Braden Scale

 

 

2. National Pressure Ulcer Advisory Panel Scale

National Pressure Ulcer Advisory Panel Scale

 

 

3. Stirling’s Pressure Ulcer Severity Scale

 

Stirling's Pressure Ulcer Severity Scale

 

 

 

 

Quiz: Identifying stages of pressure ulcers

 

What stage is the pressure ulcer (as seen in the picture below) based on the NPUAP tool?

 

Stage 1

Stage 1

 

 

Stage 2

Stage 2

 

 

 


 

 

Stage 3

Stage 3

 

 

 

Stage 4

Stage 4

 

 

 

Quiz: Identifying reflex pathways

 

Which of the figures below demonstrates a reflex pathway that may underlie hyperactive phasic stretch reflexes of spasticity?

 

 

Phasic stretch reflex.  This picture shows reflex pathways that may underlie hyperactive phasic stretch reflexes of spasticity. 

 

 

 

Tonic stretch reflex arc.  This picture shows reflex pathways that may underlie hyperactive tonic stretch reflexes of spasticity.

 

 

 

Cutaneomuscular (flexor withdrawal) reflex.  This picture shows reflex pathways that may underlie the hyperactive cutaneomuscular reflex of spasticity.

 

 

 

Case 6: Mr. RB

Mr. RB is a 70-year-old retired university economics professor. Prior to his SCI he lived independently in a wheelchair accessible apartment style condominium, had a grown child who lived across the country, and exercised at the local gym every weekday morning at 6 am. This fit gentleman of 180 lbs, 5’9” with no other significant co-morbidities was involved in a hit and run collision while walking to the gym early one morning, and two weeks post injury was admitted to a spinal cord injury rehabilitation unit. He was examined on day 14 post injury. He was out of spinal shock and described as having an AIS C T12 level spinal cord injury. A new member of the clinical team is uncertain what this means and therefore the team decides to do a refresher in service on the American Spinal Injury Association(ASIA) International Standards for Neurological Classification of Spinal Cord Injury used to assess the patient. 

Understanding SCI Classification

ASIA International Standards for Neurological Classification of Spinal Cord Injury

 

1. What do the ASIA International Standards for Neurological Classification of Spinal Cord Injury test?

  1. The International Standards for Neurological Classification of SCI categorize motor and sensory impairments in individuals with SCI. 
  2. They identify sensory and motor levels indicative of the lowest spinal levels demonstrating “unimpaired” function.

 

2. Describe the ASIA International Standards for Neurological Classification of Spinal Cord Injury test.

  1. 28 dermatomes are assessed bilaterally using pinprick and light touch sensation and 10 key muscles are assessed bilaterally with manual muscle testing.
  2. The results are summed to produce overall sensory and motor scores and are used in combination with evaluation of anal sensory and motor function as a basis for the determination of the ASIA Impairment Scale (AIS).

 

3. Describe how sensory and motor function are scored in the ASIA International Standards for Neurological Classification of Spinal Cord Injury.

  1. A clinical examination is conducted to test whether sensation is 0= “absent”, 1=”impaired” or 2=”normal”. Muscle function is rated from 0=”total paralysis” to 5=”(normal), i.e. active movement, full ROM against significant resistance”. 
  2. The presence of anal sensation and voluntary anal contraction are assessed as a yes/no.
  3. Bilateral motor and sensory levels and the AIS are based on the results of these examinations.
  4. A more accurate representation of motor function has been demonstrated when overall ASIA motor scores are divided into separate upper and lower limb scores. 

 

4. This patient is a AIS C.  What does this mean?

AIS C represents an incomplete level of injury where there is sacral sparing and more than half (more than 50 %) of the key muscles below the neurologic level of injury have a muscle grade less than 3/5.

The above flash video explains the difference between a complete and incomplete injury.

"Graphic reproduced with permission of SCI-U (Go to
http://www.spinalcordconnections.ca/Spotlight/Spotlight-Content-1.aspx to
see eLearning modules about SCI)

 

 

5. What are the advantages of the ASIA International Standards for Neurological Classification of Spinal Cord Injury test?

  1. The standards are widely used for research and clinical purposes and have high content validity (See Table 1 for Psychometric Summary).
  2. ASIA motor scores collected early following injury have some predictive validity in explaining functional outcomes.

 

6. What are the disadvantages of the ASIA International Standards for Neurological Classification of Spinal Cord Injury test?

Inter-rater reliability for assignment of motor and sensory levels and AIS classifications is less than optimal (See Table 1 for Psychometric Summary).

Summary - American Spinal Injury Association: International Standards for Neurological Classification of Spinal Cord Injury (ASIA)

Practicality

Interpretability

The AIS scores are clearly defined and understood by most clinicians.  The AIS (5 point ordinal scale) classifies individuals from “A” (complete SCI) to “E” (normal sensory and motor function).  Preservation of function in the sacral segments (S4-S5) is key for determining the AIS.

Acceptability

The assessment is generally well tolerated although sensory testing can be problem with severe hypersensitivity and testing for voluntary anal contraction can result in the stimulation of a bowel movement.

Feasibility

Takes approximately 20 minutes to conduct/score. Training is mandatory and no specialized equipment is required.

Summary

Table 1.  ASIA Psychometric Summary:

Reliability

Validity

Responsiveness

Rigor

Results

Rigor

Results

Rigor

Results

Floor/ceiling

+++

TR ++

++

Construct +++

N/A

N/A

N/A

 

 

For more information, please see: American Spinal Injury Association: International Standards for Neurological Classification of Spinal Cord Injury.

Neurogenic Bowel

Mr. RB was admitted from acute care to the spinal cord injury rehabilitation unit with significant constipation. He required a course of oral laxatives, enemas, and disimpaction to empty his bowels requiring several days.

Michelle R is the nurse responsible for Mr. RB as well as several other patients with acute traumatic spinal cord injuries at various levels. She is new to the unit, and interested in discussing with you bowel dysfunction in both the upper motor neuron bowel syndrome and the lower motor neuron bowel syndrome.

Management of neurogenic bowels in patients with SCI

7.  Describe how different SCI levels influence bowel function following SCI.

Depending on the level of injury, there are two distinct patterns in the clinical presentation of bowel dysfunction:

  1. Injury above the conus medullaris results in upper motor neuron (UMN) bowel syndrome.  The UMN bowel syndrome is typically associated with constipation and fecal retention.
  2. Injury at the level of the conus medullaris and cauda equina results in lower motor neuron (LMN) bowel syndrome. LMN bowel syndrome is commonly associated with constipation, dry, hard stool and a significant risk of incontinence (due to incomplete anal sphincter).

UMN bowel syndrome, or hyperreflexic bowel, is characterized by increased colonic wall and anal tone.Voluntary (cortical) control of the external anal sphincter is disrupted while the sphincter remains tight, thereby promoting retention of stool.  However, the nerve connections between the spinal cord below the level of the lesion and the colon remain intact; therefore, there is preserved reflex coordination and stool propulsion. The UMN bowel syndrome is typically associated with constipation and fecal retention at least in part due to external anal sphincter activity.  Stool evacuation in these individuals occurs by means of reflex activity caused by a stimulus introduced into the rectum, such as an irritant suppository or digital stimulation.

LMN bowel syndrome, or areflexic bowel, is characterized by the loss of centrally-mediated (spinal cord) peristalsis and slow stool propulsion.  A segmental colonic peristalsis occurs only due to the activity of the intrinsic myenteric plexus, resulting in the production of drier and round- shaped stool.  LMN bowel syndrome is commonly associated with constipation and a significant risk of incontinence due to the atonic external anal sphincter and lack of control over the levator ani muscle that causes the lumen of the rectum to open.

Causes and symptoms of bowel dysfunction are shown in Figure 2.  Completeness of Injury also has a significant impact on bowel function in individuals with SCI.  Those with an incomplete injury may retain the sensation of rectal fullness and ability to evacuate bowels so no specific bowel program may be required.

 

Figure 2.Causes and symptoms of bowel dysfunction.

Physical character of stool is the pivotal variable that can shift the balance in either direction.  Small, hard stool shifts the fulcrum to the left and more pressure is required to evacuate.  Soft, bulky stool causes the fulcrum to shift the opposite way.

 

 

Figure 3. Balance of forces favoring continence or bowel evacuation.  Physical character of stool is the pivotal variable that can shift the balance in either direction.  Small, hard stool shifts the fulcrum to the left and more pressure is required to evacuate.  Soft, bulky stool causes the fulcrum to shift the opposite way.

 

Michelle R, the nurse doing Mr. RB’s bowel care, describes that Mr. RB has large round hard stools in his rectum when bowel care is performed. This “bowel routine “consists of milk of magnesia given 12 hours before a planned digital stimulation. He additionally gets disimpacted following digital stimulation only if required. He also takes docusate sodium twice a day and a fiber supplement once a day and 2L per day of water. In addition, she finds that moderate sized round hard stools can be routinely found in the rectum even on days when he is not having a bowel routine.

Joanne K is the charge nurse on this spinal cord rehabilitation unit, and helps Michelle R design a multi-faceted bowel management program for this patient.  Joanne K teaches Michelle R how to trial various positions and maneuvers with the patients in order to find the best one for them.

Understand the components, rationale and research for the various aspects of a multi-faceted bowel program.

8.  What are the various components that make up a multi-faceted bowel management program?

The various components of a multi-faceted bowel management program include:

  1. Appropriate fluids, diet, and activity
  2. Appropriate rectal stimulant and rectal stimulation initially to trigger defecation daily
  3. Optimal scheduling and positioning
  4. Appropriate assistive techniques
  5. Evaluation of medications that promote or inhibit bowel function
  6. Consistent schedule for defecation established based on factors that influence elimination, pre-injury patterns of elimination, and anticipated life demands.
  7. Mechanical and/or chemical rectal stimulation to evacuate stool
  8. Use of individualized assistive techniques, push-ups, abdominal massage, Valsalva maneuver, deep breathing, ingestion of warm fluids, and a seated or forward-leaning position to aid in bowel emptying.

The Consortium for Spinal Cord Medicine developed guidelines for neurogenic bowel management.  A comprehensive evaluation of bowel function, impairment, and possible problems is recommended at the onset of SCI and at least once annually.  The evaluation may include a patient history, physical exam, an assessment of the ability of the individual or his caregiver to perform procedures safely and effectively, as well as of the bowel program design, assistive techniques/devices used, and the patient’s diet. Bowel programs should be initiated during acute care and continued throughout life, unless full recovery of bowel function returns.  Differences in bowel programs for reflexic and areflexic bowels include type of rectal stimulant, consistency of stool, and frequency of bowel care.

Improving the movement of stool through the GI tract is the most important part of any bowel management protocol following SCI.  An array of interventions, as components of a bowel routine, is recommended for the management of neurogenic bowel following SCI. These include dietary recommendations, anorectal/perianal stimulation, timing the performance of the bowel routine with food intake (thus taking advantage of gastro-colonic and recto-colonic reflexes), and a variety of pharmacological agents.

The step-wise management recommended for fecal impaction is first manual evacuation, then if not successful, oral stimulants, and finally oil retention enemas. To minimize the development of hemorrhoids, oral agents (to maintain soft-formed stool), minimize straining during bowel efforts, and minimal physical trauma during anal stimulation are recommended. Once hemorrhoids have developed, topical anti-inflammatory creams or suppositories are suggested as early treatment.

For more information, please see: Multi-Faceted Bowel Management Program.

 

9.  What is the evidence for a multi-faceted bowel management program?

  1. There is level 4 evidence that a multifaceted bowel management program reduces gastrointestinal transit time, incidences of difficult evacuations, and duration of time required for bowel management.
  2. There is limited evidence supporting a multifaceted program for managing a neurogenic bowel although it remains established practice.

 

 

Leana R, the dietician on the SCI team, suggests that Mr. RB increase the amount of fiber in his diet, in order to help with bowel management. After a few days on the new diet, Mr. RB complains of worsening constipation.

Understand the rationale and evidence for fibre use in bowel management.

10. What is the effect of dietary fibre on bowel function in persons with SCI?

  1. There is level 4 evidence that indicates high fiber diets may actually increase colonic transit time.
  2. There is a need for further research to examine the optimal level of dietary intake in spinal cord injured patients.

Soluble dietary fibres mix with water in the intestine to form a gel-like substance, which acts as a trap to collect certain body wastes and then move them out of the body. Insoluble fibers absorb and hold water, producing uniform stool and helping to push content of the gut through the digestive system quickly. Insoluble fibers promote regularity and treat constipation.

The Consortium for Spinal Cord Medicine recommends an initial diet with no less than 15 grams of fiber daily. The most common source of dietary fiber is bran.  It is not recommended to place individuals with SCI on high fiber diets.

SCIRE found limited (level 4) evidence that indicates high fiber diets may increase colonic transit time.

For more information, please see: Dietary Fibre.

 

Michelle R finds that the multi-faceted bowel care program has improved Mr. RB’s constipation. However, Michelle R has noticed that various forms of rectal stimulation have been successfully used by other patients and recommends this to Mr. RB.

Review various forms of rectal/bowel stimulation.

11.  What are the various forms of rectal stimulation and what is the evidence for each?

  1. Forms of rectal stimulation are digital rectal stimulation, electrical stimulation of abdominal muscles, functional magnetic stimulation, sacral anterior root stimulation, praxis FES system and posterior tibial nerve stimulation. 
  2. Digital rectal stimulation increases motility in the left colon in individuals with SCI.
  3. Electrical stimulation of the abdominal wall muscles can improve bowel management for individuals with tetraplegia.
  4. Functional magnetic stimulation may reduce colonic transit time in individuals with SCI.
  5. Sacral anterior root stimulation reduces severe constipation in individuals with SCI.
  6. Posterior tibial nerve stimulation is a relatively new treatment and while preliminary results show promise, the sample size is limited and more research is needed to warrant the use of this new modality. 

SCIRE found limited (level 4) evidence that digital rectal stimulation increases motility in the left colon. This involves inserting finger into rectum, rotating finger slowly for 15-30 seconds and then removing (may be repeated twice at 5 minute intervals, if needed). Figure 4 shows digital rectal stimulation.


 

Figure 4. Digital rectal stimulation.  From Memorial University of Newfoundland (2010).

The above flash video provides directions for self digital rectal stimulation.

"Graphic reproduced with permission of SCI-U (Go to
http://www.spinalcordconnections.ca/Spotlight/Spotlight-Content-1.aspx to
see eLearning modules about SCI)

Sacral Anterior Root Stimulation

There is moderate (level 2) evidence that supports the use of sacral anterior root stimulation to reduce severe constipation in complete injuries. Figure 5 shows sacral anterior root stimulation.


 

Figure 5. Sacral anterior root stimulation organization where an implant sends electrical signals through electrodes to the nerves that lead to the bladder and bowel. The user controls the implant with the external control box. This is about the size of a personal stereo/CD player. 

Sacral Anterior Root Stimulator" web page for the case studies, from where it was used:
Duke of Cornwall Spinal Treatment Centre.  (2009).  Sacral Anterior Root Stimulator.  Retrieved from http://www.spinalinjurycentre.org.uk/information/006.asp?UType=1&CType=1

 

Electrical Stimulation of the Abdominal Wall Muscles

There is strong (level 1) evidence that electrical stimulation of the abdominal wall muscles can improve bowel management for individuals with tetraplegia.  Figure 6 shows electrode placement for anterior electrical stimulation.


 

Figure 6. Schematic showing electrode placement for anterior electrical stimulation

 

Mr. RB is having improved success with his bowel routine, and now has anticipated bowel movements every two days, with the help of a personalized multifaceted routine. However, Mr. RB is embarrassed by the small volume stool incontinence he experiences during physiotherapy, which is scheduled 1 hour after his bowel routine time. Mr. RB wonders if this is occurring because of retained stool in the rectum. Mr. RB notices his roommate uses rectal irrigation after each bowel movement and Mr. RB wonders if this would be a good option for him.

Review rationale and practical utility of colonic irrigation.

12.  What is rectal irrigation as applied to the bowel, when is it indicated and what is the evidence for its use?

  1. Pulsed water irrigation removes stool in individuals with SCI and transanal irrigation alleviates constipation and fecal incontinence.
  2. Often, more than one procedure is necessary for individuals who are unable to achieve an effective bowel routine.

Pulse water irrigation consists of supplying intermittent, rapid pulses of warm water into the rectum to break up stool impactions and to stimulate peristalsis. The Peristeen Anal Irrigation system consists of a rectal balloon catheter, a manual pump, and a water container. The catheter is inserted into the rectum and the balloon inflated to hold the catheter in place while a tap water enema is administered with the manual pump.

SCIRE found limited (level 4) evidence that supports using pulsed water irrigation (intermittent rapid pulses) to remove stool in individuals with SCI. 

There is strong (level 1) evidence that supports the use of transanal irrigation (Peristeen Anal Irrigation system) over conservative bowel treatment.

For more information, please see: Irrigation Techniques.

 

Mr. RB is still having significant bowel issues. Before recommending colostomy, the pros and cons of the Malone Antegrade Continence Enema (MACE) are discussed by the general surgeon with his team.

Understand the rational, complications, outcomes for MACE and what the procedure involves.

13.   What is a Malone Antegrade Continence Enema, when is it indicated and what is the evidence that supports this procedure?

  1. The Malone Antegrade Continence Enema (MACE) is an approach using a surgically-created entry into the large intestine to irrigate the intestine.
  2. The Malone Antegrade Continence Enema is a safe and effective treatment for severe, chronic gastrointestinal problems in persons with SCI where conservative bowel management options are unsuccessful.

The procedure consists of re-implanting the appendix into the cecum and bringing the other end to the abdominal wall, thus forming an appendicostomy. Consequently, a catheter can be introduced to the patient through the stoma and an enema administered.

SCIRE found limited (level 4) evidence that the Malone Antegrade Continence Enema and Enema Continence Catheter successfully treat the neurogenic bowel.   Figure 7 shows the Malone antegrade continence enema procedure.



Figure 7. The Malone antegrade continence enema procedure provides a catheterizable channel through which antegrade colonic washout can be performed. (Reprinted with permission from Malone PSJ. Malone procedure for antegrade continence enemas. In: Spitz L, and Coran AG, eds. Rob & Smith’s Operative Surgery: Pediatric Surgery. 5th ed. London: Chapman & Hall Medical; 1995:459–467.)

For more information, please see: Malone Antegrade Continence Enema and Enema Continence Catheter.

 

At 14 months post injury, Mr. RB met with a general surgeon to discuss a colostomy for treatment of his persistent neurogenic bowel complications.

Understand the indications and benefits of a colostomy for neurogenic bowel.

14. What is a colostomy and what is the evidence that supports this procedure?

  1. Colostomy is a surgical procedure which connects part of the colon to the abdominal wall leaving an opening outside the abdominal wall for feces to exit. 
  2. Colostomy is a safe and effective treatment for severe, chronic gastrointestinal problems and perianal pressure ulcers in persons with SCI, and greatly improves their quality of life.

There is limited (level 4) evidence that colostomy reduces the number of hours spent on bowel care and simplifies bowel care routines.    Figure 8 shows a colostomy.

 

 

Figure 8. A colostomy creates an opening on the abdomen (stoma) for the drainage of feces from the large intestine.  Colostomies are usually performed after the diseased colon has been removed.  The proximal end of the healthy colon is then brought out to the skin of the abdominal wall, where it is sutured in place. An adhesive drainage bag is placed around the opening. The abdominal incision is then closed.  From Medical Illustration© 2010 Nucleus Medical Media, Inc. 
 

For more information, please see: Colostomy.

Neurogenic Bladder

At rehabilitation admission, it was apparent that Mr. RB had developed urinary retention following his SCI.  Upon examination, Mr. RB has an impaired awareness of the need to empty the bladder and also had some incontinence. His bladder management technique is intermittent catheterization.

Understand the pathophysiology of bladder dysfunction in persons with SCI.

Note: 2=normal function; 1=reduced or altered neurological function; 0=complete loss of control; NT=unable to assess due to preexisting or concomitant problems.

15.  What are the major categories of bladder dysfunction in persons with SCI?

1.    Neurogenic detrusor overactivity usually associated with sphincter         dysnergia (Detrusor external sphincter dyssynergia: DESD)

2.    Detrusor areflexia (Flaccid bladder)

3.    Detrusor overactivity without/with minimal DESD

 


Figure 10. Pathways for the control of urinary function.

 

16.  Describe the pathophysiology associated with each type of bladder dysfunction post SCI?

Detrusor External Sphincter Dysynergia

  1. Both the detrusor and the sphincter are overactive due to lack of control and descending inhibition from the pons and cortex, and both the sphincter and detrusor muscles contract reflexively when stretched.
  2. The detrusor reflexively contracts at small volumes, and contracts against an overactive sphincter, causing high pressures in the bladder.

 

Detrusor Areflexia

  1. Flaccid bladder results from injury to the sacral cord or cauda equina giving a lower motor neuron lesion and evidenced by an areflexic detrusor muscle. 
  2. The external sphincter tone tends to be flaccid, causing incontinence.  
  3. Internal sphincter tone may be intact due to the higher origin of the sympathetic innervation, in this case complete emptying, even with externally applied suprapubic pressure, may be difficult.

Detrusor Overactivity Associated with Sphincter Dysynergia (DESD)

This type of dysfunction tends to be seen in those with injuries of the spinal cord affecting the upper motor neurons (i.e. often in people with L1 spinal level lesions or above.) In these cases, the lack of coordination of the sphincter and the detrusor is caused by the spinal cord lesion not allowing coordination by the pons. Both the detrusor and the sphincter are overactive due to lack of control and descending inhibition from the pons and cortex, and both sphincter and detrusor contract reflexively when stretched. The detrusor becomes small capacity, reflexively contracting at small volumes, and contracting against an overactive sphincter, causing high pressures in the bladder. This leads to incontinence (when the detrusor contracts hard enough to overcome the sphincter contraction), incomplete emptying (due to the sphincter co-contraction), and reflux (due to the high bladder pressures) with resultant recurrent bladder infections, stones, hydronephrosis, pyelonephritis, and renal failure.

Detrusor Areflexia

Flaccid bladderresults from injury to the sacral cord or cauda equina giving a lower motor neuron lesion and evidenced by areflexic detrusor.  This loss of detrusor muscle tone prevents bladder emptying and leads to bladder wall damage from over-filling, urine reflux and an increase in infection risk due to stasis. The sphincter tone also tends to be flaccid, at least the external sphincter, causing incontinence, especially with maneuvers that increase intraabdominal pressure (so-called “Valsalva” maneuvers). These maneuvers include sneezing, coughing, but more importantly for the SCI individual, straining during transfers. Internal sphincter tone may be intact due to the higher origin of the sympathetic innervation, thus complete emptying, even with externally applied suprapubic pressure, may be difficult.  Compared to DESD, patients with detrusor areflexia comprise a much smaller proportion of a SCI practice and there is very little literature examining the effectiveness of interventions in which these patients comprise a significant proportion of the subject pool. Therefore, in the present review the focus is on the literature addressing DESD therapy. In some cases, individual papers may include persons with detrusor areflexia and individual treatments or management methods may still be appropriate for and applied to those with an areflexic bladder.

 

An initial urodynamics study was done at 1 month post injury.  It demonstrates detrusor sphincter dyssynergia, high pressure bladder and a low bladder capacity.

Understand how bladder dysfunction is diagnosed.

17.  Describe the diagnosis of bladder dysfunction post SCI?

  1. Urological and physical examination
  2. Medical, social, and functional history

The neurological physical examination should focus on the abdomen, external genitalia, and perineal skin.  The sensory exam should focus on determining the level of injury in patients with SCI.  The motor examination helps to establish the level of injury and degree of completeness in patients with SCI.  Upper tract tests which evaluate renal anatomy include abdominal x-ray, intravenous peylogram and renal ultrasound.  For more detailed imaging, an abdominal computed tomography can be used.  For evaluation of 24 – hour renal function include a 24 –hour urine creatinine clearance and quantitative renal scan.  Tests which evaluate the lower tracts include cystogram, cystoscopy and urodynamics. 

Urodynamics is defined as the study of normal and abnormal factors in the storage, transport and emptying of urine from the bladder and urethra by an appropriate method.  The water fill urodynamic study has a filling phase, where water is being infused into the bladder.  Bladder sensation, bladder capacity, bladder wall compliance and bladder stability can be evaluated.  In the voiding phase (when a person told to void, or person with neurogenic bladder has an uninhibited contraction and voiding begins) evaluate leak point pressure, maximum voiding pressure, urethral sphincter activity, flow rate, voided value and PVR.  Initial testing is often done 3 -6 moths post injury or whenever bladder comes out of spinal shock. 

 

Figure 11.Water fill urodynamic set-up.  Simultaneous monitoring of various urodynamic parameters is shown.  Intravesical pressure minus intrabdominal pressure will produce the detrusor pressure (Pdet). (A) Intravesical pressure (Pves). (B) Urethral sphincter pressure (Pur). (C) Urethral sphincter electromyography. (D) Intraabdominal pressure (pabd).

Figure 12.  Anatomical classification of the neurogenic bladder

 

 

Figure 12.  Schematic representation of various voiding patterns. (A). Normal.  (B). Uninhibited contractions occur with filling.  The sphincter is attempting to inhibit contractions.  Patient has a normal voiding phase.   (C). No bladder contractions.  Rises in bladder pressure are due to rises in abdominal pressure (D).  Uninhibited contractions occur with simultaneous sphincter contractions (i.e.detrusor sphincter dysnergia). (Pabd, intrabdominal pressure; Pur urethral sphincter pressure; Pves, intravesical pressure).

 

Figure 13a. Appearance of normal urodynamic study.  Cytometrogram is shown. Bladder filling is sensed at approximately 200 ml.  The external urethral sphincter is then activated to maintain continence.  At bladder capacity (400 – 500 ml) when bladder voiding is consciously initiated the bladder contracts generating intravesical pressures of 40 – 80 cm H20 and the external sphincter relaxes in a coordinated fashion to allow for complete bladder emptying.

 

Figure 13b. Urodynamic study characteristic of detrusor hypereflexia with sphincter dyssnergia.  Bladder contraction occurs at low bladder volumes.  The urethral sphincter contract as well instead of relaxing during bladder contraction, resulting in extremely high intravesical pressures (greater than 100 cm H20) and incomplete bladder emptying.

 

Figure 13c. Urodynamic study characteristic of detrusor and urethral sphincter reflexia.  Minimal or no bladder contractions are generated, even with bladder filling to high bladder volumes (greater than 500 ml.)  There is minimal urethral sphincter activity during bladder filling.

 

Table 2. Bladder Dysfunction based on Lesion Location

Lesion Location

Urodynamic Study Pattern

Rostral to pons

Detrusor hyperreflexia with coordinated sphincters

Between pons and sacral spinal cord

Detrusor hyperreflexia with sphincter dyssnergia

Sacral spinal cord

Detrusor and sphincter areflexia

Normal detrusor function with areflexic sphincter

Cauda equina or peripheral nerves

Detrusor and sphincter areflexia

 

At 1 months post injury, Mr. RB developed urinary incontinence between catheterizations. It is small volume incontinence, and usually comes just before catheterizations when the bladder is relatively full. It does not dribble out, but instead forms a strong short stream with a UTI ruled out.

He is interested in discussing treatment options with you.

Understand the management of bladder filling.

18. What is the evidence for pharmacological methods of enhancing bladder volume while lowering bladder filling pressures?

A.   Anticholinergic Therapy

  1. There is strong evidence that propiverine, oxybutynin, tolterodine and trospium chloride are efficacious anticholinergic agents for the treatment of SCI neurogenic bladder.
  2. Oxybutynin co-treatment with verapamil may enhance the standard formulation of oxybutynin in the treatment of SCI detrusor hyperreflexia.
  3. Tolterodine likely results in less dry mouth but is similar in efficacy to oxybutynin.

 

B.   Detrusor muscle De-innervation Therapy

  1. There is strong evidence that botulinum toxin A injections into the detrusor muscle provide targeted treatment for detrusor hyperreflexia and urge incontinence resistant to high-dose oral anticholinergic treatments with intermittent self-catheterization in SCI.

 

C.   Detrusor Muscle Analgesia Therapy

1.Strong (level 1) evidence supports the use of vanillanoid compounds such as capsaicin or resiniferatoxin to increase maximum bladder capacity and decrease urinary frequency and leakages in neurogenic detrusor overactivity of spinal origin.

2.Limited (level 4) evidence exists to suggest that intravesical capsaicin instillation in bladders of SCI individuals does not increase the rate of common bladder cancers after 5 years of use. 

3.Strong (level 1) evidence supports the use of N/OFG, a nociceptin orphan peptide receptor agonist for the treatment of neurogenic bladder in SCI.

D.   Intravesical Instillations

  1. Limited (level 4) evidence states that intravesical instillations with oxybutinun or propantheline are ineffective for treating neurogenic bladder in people with SCI.

 

E.    Other Pharmaceutical Treatments

1.    Intrathecal baclofen or clonidine may be beneficial for bladder function improvement but further confirmatory evidence is needed.

A.  Anticholinergic Therapy for SCI-Related Detrusor Hyperactivity

The body of the detrusor is smooth muscle that contains muscarinic receptors that are triggered by acetylcholine to cause contraction of the muscle. To relax the detrusor and allow it to fill with higher volumes under lower pressure, anticholinergics may be used.

Propiverine

Propiverine has both anticholinergic and calcium channel blocking properties thus decreases involuntary smooth muscle contractions. SCIRE found 15mg tid administration of propiverine over 2 weeks yielded significant improvement of SCI detrusor hyperreflexia represented by increased maximal cystometric bladder capacity.  

Oxybutynin

Oxybutynin is an anticholinergic agent used extensively clinically to treat overactive bladder, yet few studies have been performed on the neurogenic population with this medication.  Newer versions of oxybutynin in longer acting forms have sparked renewed interest in this medication with the hopes to decrease side effects seen with the short acting oxybutynin.  

Controlled-release oxybutynin was efficacious for SCI individuals with detrusor hyperreflexia as reflected by significantly increased bladder volume with decreased mean number of voids per 24 hours (Level 4).  However, post-void residual volumes, nocturia and weekly incontinence episodes did not change significantly.  Although oxybutynin is commonly chosen to treat overactive bladder, it is accompanied by annoying side effects such as dry mouth. 

Tolterodine

A newer anticholinergic, tolterodine, causes less dry mouth and has also been shown to be efficacious for the treatment of neurogenic bladder dysfunction.  Tolterodine has been shown to be significantly better at increasing intermittent catheterization (IC) volumes (p<0.0005) and reducing incontinence (p<0.001) but was similar in its effects on cystometric bladder capacity when compared to placebo.  

Trospium Chloride

Trospium chloride is an anticholinergic medication that is reported not to cross the blood-brain barrier.  Highly significant (p<0.001) responses were found in favour of trospium chloride vs placebo for increased  bladder capacity and compliance, and decreased bladder pressure with low side effects and no effect on flow rate and residual urine volumes. SCIRE found that tolterodine improved reflex volumes, cystometric capacity, and maximum detrusor pressures.

For more information, please see: Anticholinergic Therapy.

B.   Muscle Deinnervation Therapy for SCI-Related Detrusor Hyperactivity

Botulinum Toxin

Botulinum toxin is a chemo-denervation agent that blocks the presynaptic release of acetylcholine when injected into the muscle. A promising emerging use is for neurogenic detrusor overactivity treatment in individuals with SCI. The advantage of botulinum toxin over systemic drug administration of medications such as anti-cholinergics is the treatment of discrete portions of the dysfunctional voiding process. Application of botulinum toxin focally to the detrusor directs the drug to the area of need and avoids systemic side effects.

SCIRE found significant decrease in incontinence and a significant drop in maximum detrusor pressure post botulinum toxin detrusor wall injection.

A different form of botulinum toxin A, Dysport, was found to improve continence, cystometric capacity, and decrease pressure.

For more information, please see:Toxin Therapy.

C.   Decreased Sensory Input – Detrusor Analgesics

Capsaicin

The use of capsaicin (CAP), a vanilloid, as a topical temporary analgesic is not uncommon as evidenced by over-the-counter ointments available for purchase in local pharmacies.  Localized and reversible antinociception by capsaicin is a result of induced C-fibre conduction and subsequent neuropeptide release inactivation.  Although C-fibers are not involved in normal voiding, neuroplastic changes to C-fiber bladder afferent growth account for injury emergent C-fiber mediated voiding reflex (i.e., spinal detrusor hyperreflexia). 

SCIRE found strong (level 1) evidence in support of the ability of CAP to improve bladder function (decrease frequency and leakages) by increasing bladder capacity.  However, there was a significant side effect of causing autonomic dysreflexia in a small number of patients following CAP.

Resiniferatoxin

Resiniferatoxin (RTX) is another vanilloid which has been studied for its similar beneficial effects, with less irritation to the bladder and thus better tolerated.  By chemically decreasing C-fiber bladder afferent influence with intravesical vanilloids (i.e., CAP, RTX) bladder contractility is decreased and bladder capacity is increased.  RTX was similarly effective in increasing bladder capacity when compared to CAP.   

SCIRE found RTX was responsible for significantly increased volume of first involuntary detrusor contraction, maximum cystometric capacity, decreased urinary frequency (p=0.01) and incontinence (p=0.03) with similar side effects as compared to placebo.

Nociception/orphanin phenylalanine glutamine (N/OFG)

Nociception/orphanin phenylalanine glutamine (N/OFG) is a heptadecapeptide that acts on sensory innvervation of the lower urinary tract in a similar fashion to CAP and RTX. It activates the G protein coupled receptor nociceptin orphan peptide and thus has an inhibitory effect on the micturition reflex in the rat.  The authors conclude that this inhibition of the micturition reflex supports nociceptin orphan peptide receptor agonists as a possible new treatment for neurogenic bladders of SCI patients.

For more information, please see: Toxin Therapy.

 

In addition to the issues of bladder filling, Mr. RB also has issues with bladder emptying.  He is interested in pharmacologic treatments to improve bladder emptying (while still maintaining low bladder filling pressures), since he has the long term goal of no longer requiring intermittent catheterization.

Understand the management of bladder emptying.

19.   What is the evidence for each pharmacological method of facilitating bladder emptying?

Alpha-adrenergic Blockers for Bladder Emptying

  1. Terazosin may be an alternative treatment for bladder neck dysfunction in individuals with SCI; however side effects and drug tolerance should be monitored.
  2. Six months of alpha 1-blocker therapy in male SCI patients may improve upper tract stasis.

 

Botulinum Toxin

Botulinum toxin injected into the sphincter is effective in assisting with bladder emptying for persons with neurogenic bladder due to SCI.

Alpha-Adrenergic Blockers

These drugs have been used to target alpha adrenoreceptor blocker subtypes which may be specifically focused on a variety of mechanisms including bladder neck dysfunction, increased bladder outlet resistance, detrusor-sphincter dyssynergia, autonomic hyperreflexia or upper tract stasis.

 

Terazosin

Terazosin is often used to treat hypertension. However, this alpha-adrenergic blocker is also useful in treating bladder neck dysfunction by relaxing the bladder neck muscles and easing the voiding process. SCIRE found limited (level 4) evidence to support terazosin as an alternative treatment for bladder neck dysfunction in SCI individuals provided that side effects and drug tolerance are monitored.

 

Duration of Alpha 1-Blocker Therapy

SCIRE found limited (level 4) evidence that in men with upper tract (i.e. kidneys and ureters) stasis secondary to SCI at or above T6, 6 months of alpha1-blocker therapy provided improvement in upper tract stasis in 80% of subjects, who used reflex voiding to manage their bladder as measured by significant decreases of the duration of uninhibited contractions. 

 

For more information, please see: Alpha-Adrenergic Blockers.

 

Botulinum Toxin for Bladder Emptying

 

Botulinum Toxin is an exotoxin produced by the bacteria Clostridium botulinum. It has been used for many conditions associated with muscular overactivity and specifically for neurogenic detrusor overactivity. The toxin works by inhibiting acetylcholine release at the neuromuscular junction and relaxing the muscle.

 

Botulinum Toxin Injected into the External Urinary Sphincter

In SCI individuals with drainage impairment, botulinum toxin may also be administered into the external urethral sphincter causing the muscle to relax and drainage to occur. SCIRE found strong (level 1) evidence that botulinum toxin therapy injection relaxes the external sphincter resulting in a decrease in post-voiding residual urine volume and an increase in voiding urine flow.  This improvement further results in decreasing other symptoms such as autonomic dysreflexia. However, due to sphincter denervation in almost all subjects, it has a disadvantage of requiring repeated injections to maintain its therapeutic results.

 

 

After 1 year, Mr. RB has already tried oral anticholinergic (e.g. trospium) for filling, alpha blockers (flonax, hytrin, cardura) for the emptying, and a 6 month trial of Botulinum toxin injection into the sphincter for emptying unsuccessfully. He now wonders about non-pharmacological options. Also, the symptoms of discomfort and small volume urinary incontinence at low bladder volumes are socially embarrassing and require that he wear a continence undergarment.

Mr. RB asks if there are any non-pharmacological methods to increase bladder volume and lower bladder filling pressures.  One of these options includes electrical stimulation, a new technique adopted by the centre, which has been shown to be helpful in increasing bladder filling capacity at low pressures.

Understanding non-pharmacological management of DESD.

 

20.  What evidence is present for enhancing bladder volume, while lowering bladder filling pressures through non-pharmacological methods?

  1. Electrical Stimulation.
  2. Surgical augmentation of bladder may result in enhanced bladder capacity under lower filling pressure and improved continence in persons with SCI.
  3. Extraperitoneal vs intraperitoneal augmentation enterocystoplasty may result in better postoperative recovery.

Electrical Stimulation to Enhance Bladder Volumes

Electrical stimulation, most notably anterior sacral root stimulation, has been used to enhance bladder volume and induce voiding. Typically, this approach has involved concomitant dorsal sacral rhizotomy and implantation of a sacral nerve stimulator. The combined effect of this is a more compliant bladder with more storage capacity under lower pressure and triggered voiding resulting in reduced incontinence.

For more information, please see: Electrical Stimulation.


Surgical Augmentation of the Bladder to Enhance Volume

Bladder augmentation or augmentation cystoplasty is a surgical repair to the bladder typically suggested when conservative approaches such as anticholinergics with intermittent catheterization have failed to create an adequate bladder volume under low pressure for storage.

SCIRE foundlevel 4 evidence that surgical augmentation of bladder (ileocystoplasty) may result in enhanced bladder capacity under lower filling pressure and improved continence in persons with SCI who previously did not respond well to conservative approaches for overactive bladder.

Extraperitoneal (vs intraperitoneal) augmentation enterocystoplasty produces equivocal postoperative continence with easier early postoperative recovery (Level 3).

 

 

Figure 14.

Augmentation cytoplasty: a 30 cm segment of small bowel is opened and reconstructed as a U-shaped patch and then sewn into the bivalve bladder.

For more information, please see: Surgical Augmentation.

Quiz: ASIA Impairment Scale

 

Based on the ASIA Impairment sheet below, which of the following answers describes the correct neurological level of injury.

 

a. 

 

b.

 

c.

 

Quiz: Urodynamics

 

Which of the following urodynamic studies below represents an hypereflexic bladder?

 

Appearance of normal urodynamic study.  Cytometrogram is shown. Bladder filling is sensed at approximately 200 ml.  The external urethral sphincter is then activated to maintain continence.  At bladder capacity (400 – 500 ml) when bladder voiding is consciously initiated the bladder contracts generating intravescical pressures of 40 – 80 cm H20 and the external sphincter relaxes in a coordinated fashion to allow for complete bladder emptying.

Urodynamic study characteristic of detrusor hypereflexia with sphincter dyssnergia.  Bladder contraction occurs at low bladder volumes.  The urethral sphincter contract as well instead of relaxing during bladder contraction, resulting in extremely high intravescical pressures (greater than 100 cm H20) and incomplete bladder emptying. 

Urodynamic study characteristic of detrusor and urethral sphincter reflexia.  Minimal or no bladder contractions are generated, even with bladder filling to high bladder volumes (greater than 500 ml.)  There is minimal urethral sphincter activity during bladder filling.

Case 9: Margaret

PDF Download: 

Margaret is a 45 year old woman who has been working as a personal support worker in a group home for the past 14 years.  She has a long history of back pain, and has been experiencing progressive difficulty with walking over the last year.  A recent MRI showed multiple disc herniations, with compression at C5-C6.  She was diagnosed with cervical spondylosis, and underwent a surgical laminectomy 1 month ago.  As a result of the cervical compression, she experienced a C5-C6 spinal cord injury which was classified as an ASIA Impairment Scale (AIS) D.

Figure 1. Cervical disc herniations at C4-5 and C5-C6 with spinal cord compression at C5-6.

 

Orthostatic Hypotension

Margaret complains of feeling lightheaded when being stood up by the attendants.  It is actually interfering with her transfers and limits her standing tolerance.  The nurse questions whether the patient is suffering from orthostatic hypotension (OH).

Understanding orthostatic hypotension post SCI.

 

1. How common is orthostatic hypotension following SCI?

  1. The prevalence of OH is greater in patients with higher spinal cord lesions, and thus it is more common in tetraplegia.
  2. Individuals with cervical SCI also experience greater posture-related decreases in blood pressure than those with paraplegia. 

 

2.  What factors lead to orthostatic hypotension in individuals with SCI?

The factors that lead to orthostatic hypotension are multifactorial:          

  1. Loss of tonic sympathetic control            
  2. Altered baroreceptor sensitivity               
  3. Lack of skeletal muscle pumps               
  4. Cardiovascular deconditioning                
  5. Altered salt and water balance                

The low level of efferent sympathetic nervous activity and the loss of the reflex vasoconstriction following SCI are the two major causes of OH.  The decrease in blood pressure following the change to an upright position in individuals with SCI may be related to excessive pooling of blood in the abdominal viscera and lower extremities. This decrease is compounded by the loss of lower extremity muscle function post-SCI that is known to be important in counteracting venous pooling in the upright position. The reduced ventricular filling and emptying ultimately lead to a reduction in cardiac output, and thus, arterial pressure (provided the reductions in cardiac output are marked). Unloading of the arterial baroreceptors induces a reflexic reduction in cardiac parasympathetic (vagal) activity. As a result, tachycardia may occur, although this is usually insufficient to compensate for decreased stroke volume.  A reduction in cardiac output results and in turn, arterial blood pressure is reduced. Subsequently, pooling of blood in the lower extremities and decreased blood pressure results in reduced cerebral flow, which presents as a number of signs and symptoms.  Figure 2. shows factors which lead to orthostatic hypotension post SCI.

 

In addition to central causes of OH following SCI, there is also some evidence suggesting peripheral contributions. For example, upregulation of the potent vasodilator nitric oxide (NO) could potentially contribute to the orthostatic intolerance in this population. Several other factors may predispose individuals with SCI to OH, including low plasma volume, hyponatremia, and cardiovascular deconditioning due to prolonged bed-rest.

 

 

Figure 3.  Factors which lead to orthostatic hypotension post SCI

Pharmacological treatments for Orthostatic Hypotension

Margaret is worried about her enlarged and tender feet due to decreased muscle and symptathetic tone.  She asks if there is a pill she could take for it.

Understanding pharmacological treatment options for OH post SCI.

 

4.  What is the evidence for pharmacological options available to manage OH following SCI?

  1. Midodrine hydrochloride should be included in the management protocolof OH in individuals with spinal cord injury.
  2. There is limited evidence that fludrocortisone is effective for the management of OH in SCI
  3. There is limited evidence that ergotamine is effective for the management of OH in SCI
  4. There is little evidence that ephedrine is effective for the management of OH in SCI
  5. There is limited evidence that L-DOPS is effective for the management of OH in SCI
  6. There is limited evidence that L-NAME is effective for the management of OH in SCI
Midrodrine

SCIRE found level 2 evidence that Midodrine enhances exercise performance in some individuals with SCI, similar to other clinical populations with cardiovascular autonomic dysfunction and that L-Name may be effective for reducing OH. 

Fludrocortisone

Fludrocortisone was not effective for OH in SCI (Level 4) .

Ergotamine

SCIRE found level 5 evidence that: Ergotamine, combined daily with fludrocortisone, may successfully prevent symptomatic OH. Ephedrine may prevent some symptoms of OH; that L-DOPS, in conjunction with salt supplementation may be effective for reducing OH.

For more information, please see: Pharmacological Management.

 

 

5.  Describe the pharmophysiological effect of each of the pharmacological options available to manage OH following SCI?

  1. Midodrine hydrochloride should be included in the management protocol of OH in individuals with spinal cord injury.  Midodrine, a selective alpha1 adrenergic agonist, activates the alpha-adrenergic receptors of the arteriolar and venous vasculature, producing an increase in vascular tone and blood pressure. 
  2. There is limited evidence that fludrocortisone is effective for the management of OH in SCI.  Fludrocortisone is a mineralocorticoid that induces more salt to be released into the bloodstream from the kidneys.
  3. There is limited evidence that ergotamine is effective for the management of OH in SCI.  Ergotamine, interacts with alpha adrenergic receptors and has selective vasoconstrictive effects on peripheral and cranial blood vessels.
  4. There is limited evidence that ephedrine is effective for the management of OH in SCI
  5. There is limited evidence that L-DOPS is effective for the management of OH in SCI.  L-DOPS is a precursor of noradrenalin and acts on the brain. 

Non-pharmacological treatments for Orthostatic Hypotension

 

Margaret wants to know what non-pharmacological options are available for orthostatic hypotension.  She asks her nurse whether she can inquire with the attending doctor for her.

Understanding non-pharmacological treatment options for OH post SCI.

 

6.  What non-pharmacological treatments are available for the treatment of orthostatic hypotension post SCI?

  1. Fluid and Salt
  2. Blood Pooling Prevention
  3. Functional Electrical Stimulation
  4. Exercise

 

7.  What is the evidence for salt-loading as a treatment for orthostatic hypotension post SCI?

The benefits of salt loading have not been sufficiently proven in individuals with SCI.

OH is common among patients with higher levels of paralysis, presents variable symptoms, and often coexists with abnormal salt and water metabolism.  Increases in fluid intake and a diet high in salt can expand extracellular fluid volume and augment orthostatic responses.

SCIRE found no evidence on the effect of salt or fluid regulation alone for OH management in SCI. Salt and fluid regulation was evaluated in combination with other pharmacological interventions and thus, the effects of salt and fluid regulation alone cannot be determined. 

 

 

8.  What is the evidence for treatments designed to prevent blood pooling in the management of orthostatic hypotension post SCI?

There is insufficient evidence that elastic stockings or abdominal binders have any effect on cardiovascular responses in SCI

The application of external counterpressure by devices such as abdominal binders or pressure stockings is thought to decrease capacitance of the vasculature beds in the legs and abdominal cavity, both major areas of blood pooling during standing.

 

There is conflicting evidence based on limited research that elastic stockings/abdominal binders have any effect on cardiovascular responses in individuals with SCI. 

 

SCIRE found level 2 evidence that application of a harness in individuals with SCI could alter baseline cardiovascular parameters and the response to orthostatic.

 

 

9.  What is the evidence for non-pharmacological treatments of orthostatic hypotension post SCI?

The use of FES is an effective adjunct treatment to minimize cardiovascular
changes during changes in position.

The application of FES triggers intermittent muscle contractions that activate the physiologic muscle pump. SCIRE foundlevel 2 evidence that FES is an important treatment adjunct to minimize cardiovascular changes during postural orthostatic stress in individuals with SCI.

 

 

10.  What is the evidence for non-pharmacological treatments of orthostatic hypotension post SCI?

  1. Simultaneous arm exercise during a tilt test is not effective for improving orthostatic tolerance.
  2. The benefits of body-weight supported treadmill training for management
    of OH have not been sufficiently proven in SCI.

Following exercise, individuals with SCI may experience improvements in the autonomic regulation of their cardiovascular system.There is also some evidence that exercise training could enhance sympathetic outflow in individuals with SCI, as shown by an increase in catecholamine response to maximal arm ergometry exercise.  There is level 2 evidence that simultaneous upper extremity exercises do not improve orthostatic tolerance during a progressive tilt exercise6 months of body-weight support treadmill training does not substantially improve orthostatic tolerance during a tilt test (Level 4).

 

For more information, please see: Non-Pharmacological Treatments.

Venous Thromboembolism

 

Margaret is experiencing pain in her leg.  The nurse thinks she may be at risk for deep venous thrombosis (DVT) because of immobilization due to injury. 

Understanding DVT post SCI.

 

11.  How common is deep venous thrombosis (DVT) in SCI patients who are not receiving prophylactic treatment?

  1. Deep venous thrombosis (DVT) and subsequent pulmonary embolism (PE) remain a significant cause of morbidity and mortality in spinal cord injured (SCI) patient
  2. Incidence of DVT has been reported by various authors to range between 9% - 100% during the acute stage of SCI with most occurring in the first 2 weeks post-injury, sometimes leading to a pulmonary embolism which remains a common cause of death
  3. Deep venous thrombosis is common in spinal cord injured patients not receiving prophylaxis

Figure 4.  Deep Vein Thrombosis:  This medical exhibit illustrates the process of clot formation in the deep veins of the leg.  From Medical Illustration© 2010 Nucleus Medical Media, Inc.

Anti-coagulation prophylaxis management

 

Anti-coagulation medication is recommended by the attending physician for deep venous thrombosis.

Understanding anti-coagulation prophylaxis management of DVT post SCI.

 

12.  What is the evidence for anti-coagulation medications such as unfractionated heparin and low molecular weight heparin in the prophylaxis of deep venous thromboembolism post SCI?

  1. There is strong evidence supporting that 5,000 units s/c q12h of unfractionated heparin does not prevent venous thrombosis post SCI while higher doses adjusted anticoagulation is more effective
  2. Low molecular weight heparin reduces the risk of venous thromboembolism post SCI more effectively than standard or unfractionated heparin prophylaxis with less bleeding complications.  See Figure 5 for anticoagulation therapy and other DVT prevention methods.
5,000 units of unfractionated heparin is recommended for motor-incomplete patients for 8 weeks and either heparin adjusted to high normal activated partial thromboplastin time or low molecular weight heparin for motor-complete patients for 8-12 weeks.

 

Unfractionated Heparin as Prophylaxis for Venous Thromboembolism PostSCI

Heparin acts as an anticoagulant by forming a complex with antithrombin, catalyzing the inhibition of several activated blood coagulation factors: XIIa, XIa, IXa, Xa and thrombin. Bleeding is the most common adverse effect of heparin.

 

Low Molecular Weight Heparin (LMWH) as ProphylaxisPost SCI

Low-molecular-weight heparin (LMWH) is derived from standard heparin through either chemical or enzymatic depolymerization. Whereas standard heparin has a molecular weight of 5,000 to 30,000 Daltons, LMWH ranges from 1,000 to 10,000 Daltons. LMWH binds less strongly to protein, has enhanced bioavailability, interacts less with platelets and yields a very predictable dose response. The clinical advantages of LMWH include predictability, dose-dependent plasma levels, a long half-life and less bleeding for a given antithrombotic effect. LMWH is administered once or twice daily, both during the high-risk period when prophylaxis for DVT is recommended and also while waiting for oral anticoagulation to take effect in the treatment of DVT.  Table 1 shows Generic and Trade-names of Low Molecular Weight Heparin.

 

Danaparoid sodium (Orgaran) is an alternative anticoagulant for patients who develop heparin-induced thrombocytopenia from heparin therapy. Danaparoid is a low molecular weight heparinoid. Its active components consist of heparan sulfate, dermatan sulfate and chondroitin sulfate. The major difference between danaparoid and other low molecular weight heparins (LMWH) is that danaparoid is devoid of heparin or heparin fragments. However, it exerts effects similarly to other LMWHs. Danaparoid acts by inactivating thrombin.

Table 1. Generic and Trade-names of Low Molecular Weight Heparin

Generic Name

Trade-name

Dalteparin

Fragmin

Danaparoid

Orgaran

Enoxaparin

Lovenox

Ardeparin

Normiflo

Parnaparin, Reviparin

Clivarine

Tinzaparin

Logiparin, Innohep

Certoporain

Alphaparin, Sandoparin

 

LMWH vs. UFH as Prophylaxis for Venous Thromboembolism Post SCI

The most commonly studied LMWH is the prophylaxis of venous thromboembolism post SCI is enoxaparin.  Enoxaparin was the first LMWH in the United States. 

 

SCIRE foundLevel 1 evidence that supports low molecular weight heparin, in particular enoxaparin, is more effective in reducing venous thromboembolic events, when compared to the standard subcutaneous heparin prophylaxis.  Moreover, the incidence of bleeding complications was less in the LMWH group.

 

There is strong evidence that LMWH in particular enoxaparin is more effective than standard UFH.

 

Figure 5.This medical illustration exhibit shows methods for preventing deep vein (venous) thrombosis (DVT) and pulmonary embolism following leg injury and surgery. The steps in this image include early ambulation, post-operatively, with a caption reading: "Therapeutic exercise following surgery reduces the risks of clots forming in the deep veins of the leg." Other steps include performing "foot pump" exercises, contracting the muscles of the lower leg; wearing graduated compression stockings (GCS); using anticoagulant therapy medication (blood thinners); intermittent pneumatic compression devices (IPCD); and surgically installing an inferior vena cava filter device (IVC filter or Greenfield filter) to catch clots in the blood stream before they reach the heart.   From Medical Illustration© 2010 Nucleus Medical Media, Inc.

 

For more information, please see:Pharmacological Agents.

 

 


Inferior vena cava filter as prophylaxis

Margaret develops a pulmonary embolus just before she is initiated on anticoagulation.  Within a day of initiating anticoagulation she suffered a serious gastrointestinal bleed.  Anticoagulation had to be discontinued but she is still felt to be at significant risk of another pulmonary embolus.  The possibility of inserting a vena cava filter is being entertained.

Understanding the use of inferior vena cava filter as prophylaxis for pulmonary embolus.

 

13.  When is it appropriate to use an IVC filter in the prevention of pulmonary emboli post SCI? What evidence is there for the use of an IVC filter in SCI?

  1. IVC filters are appropriate when the SCI patient is at high risk of suffering a PE or reoccurrence of a PE and anticoagulation is contraindicated.
  2. There is level 3 evidence that inferior vena cava filters significantly reduce the risk of pulmonary emboli in high-risk SCI patients
Vena cava filtration involves inserting a mechanical filter in the inferior vena cava to prevent devastating pulmonary emboli from occurring. It is generally recommended when the SCI patient is a high risk of suffering for a PE or often the reoccurrence of a PE and anticoagulants are contraindicated.  Figure 6 shows an IVC Filter.

 

For more information, please see:Vena Cava Filtration.

Figure 6. IVC Filter Photo courtesy of Andrew Cates. (2009).

Lower Limb

 

Margaret has weakness in her knees and ankles. It is difficult for her to stand without assistance and her muscles fatigue very quickly.  She is attempting to regain ambulation and she sees other patients in the gym using leg braces.  She wants to know if leg braces will help her.

Examining the use of mobility devices for upright support post SCI.

 

14.  What evidence is there regarding the efficiency of brace/orthotic devices for upright support and mobility?

  1. In persons with complete spinal cord injuries, the limited available evidence does not support that bracing alone will enable significant gains in functional ambulation. The advantages of bracing in such cases appear largely restricted to the general health and well-being benefits related to the practice of standing and the ability to ambulate short-distances in the home or indoor settings. The benefits of bracing alone on functional ambulation primarily involve people with incomplete spinal lesions.
  2. There is limited evidence that a combined approach of bracing and FES results in additional benefit to functional ambulation in paraplegic patients with complete SCI.

Bracing (alone) in SCI

 

There are several devices available for bracing the legs in persons with complete SCI to support standing and walking. SCIRE foundlimited level 4 evidence that bracing alone results in significant gains in functional ambulation for people with complete SCI.  However, this patient does not have a complete lesion and it must be noted that for people with incomplete SCI, bracing (AFO-use) alone during walking can enhance gait speed and endurance when compared with walking without an AFO.

 

Bracing Combined with FES in SCI

 

Hybrid systems combine conventional bracing with FES to activate large lower extremity muscles in the hopes of improving the gait pattern, reduce upper extremity exertion and improve trunk and hip stability.  Regarding this case, there is some indication that a combination of bracing and FES provides greater ambulatory function than either approach alone in incomplete SCI.

 

Figure 7a. Modular ankle-foot orthosis

 

 

Figure 7b. Knee ankle foot orthosis

 

For more information, please see:BracingandBracing with FES.

Locomotor training

Despite some success with bracing, Margaret finds it cumbersome to don/doff the braces on her own.  It is her goal to be completely independent with ambulation, and she would like to pursue other interventions with her physiotherapist that may help her to achieve this goal, without relying on bracing. 

Understanding locomotor training options post SCI.

 

15.  What is the effect of interventions which improve lower limb strength and walking ability?

  1. Locomotor training programs are beneficial in improving lower limb muscle strength although in acute SCI similar strength benefits can be obtained with conventional rehabilitation.
  2. The benefits of locomotor training on muscle strength may be realized when it is combined with conventional therapy.
  3. This should be further explored in acute, incomplete SCI where better functional outcomes may be realized with the combination of therapies.

SCIRE found significant increase of lower limb strength following locomotor training – despite variations between training protocols and specific methods employed. However, enhanced walking capability did not necessarily demonstrate parallel increases in strength. Furthermore, the clinical relevance of the small strength gains following locomotor training is questionable when considering the duration and complexity of the intervention.

 

For more information, please see: Locomotor Training.

Depression


 

Margaret has now been participating in inpatient rehabilitation for 10 weeks, and her progress has slowed compared to the gains she made initially.  Therapists and nursing staff have noticed her mood is low.  She frequently complains of fatigue, trouble concentrating, and generally feeling down.  She has started to lose weight.  She attends her therapy sessions, but is otherwise sleeping throughout the day with the curtains drawn in her room.  She is not participating in any recreation and leisure activities, and declines weekend outings. 

Her family is concerned that she is not herself these last couple of weeks – it is ‘not like her’ to sleep for 12 hours per day, so they ask the medical team if this could be related to an illness.  At rounds, the interdisciplinary team raises the possibility of depression. 

Understanding the clinical features of depression post SCI.

 

16.  Describe the clinical features of depression post SCI.

According to the DSM-IV, a diagnosis of Major Depressive Disorder in an adult requires that five (or more) of the following symptoms have been present during the same 2-week period and represent a change from previous functioning.  At least one of the symptoms is either  (1) depressed mood most of the day, nearly every day, as indicated by either subjective report (e.g., feels sad or empty) or observation made by others (e.g., appears tearful) OR (2) markedly diminished interest or pleasure in all, or almost all, activities most of the day, nearly every day (as indicated by either subjective account or observation made by others)

Other symptoms can include:

  1. Significant weight loss when not dieting or weight gain (e.g., a change of more than 5% of body weight in a month), or decrease or increase in appetite nearly every day.
  2. Insomnia or hypersomnia nearly every day.
  3. Psychomotor agitation or retardation nearly every day (observable by others, not merely subjective feelings of restlessness or being slowed down)
  4. Fatigue or loss of energy nearly every day.
  5. Feelings of worthlessness or excessive or inappropriate guilt (which may be delusional) nearly every day (not merely self-reproach or guilt about being sick).
  6. Diminished ability to think or concentrate, or indecisiveness, nearly every day (either by subjective account or as observed by others).
  7. Recurrent thoughts of death (not just fear of dying), recurrent suicidal ideation without a specific plan, or a suicide attempt or a specific plan for committing suicide.

 

The symptoms cause clinically significant distress or impairment in social, occupational, or other important areas of functioning.

 

The symptoms are not due to the direct physiological effects of a substance (e.g., a drug of abuse, a medication) or a general medical condition (e.g., hypothyroidism).

 

 

Margaret acknowledges that her mood is lower than usual, but she thinks it is related to her new onset of disability and that she will “snap out of it” in a few days.  She has been subsequently diagnosed with depression by her physiatrist who thinks that her decline in mood and functioning might be addressed through a pharmacological intervention.   

Examining the impact of depression.

 

17. What is the impact of depression on functioning in individuals with SCI?

  1. Depression is a common consequence of SCI.
  2. Depression post SCI can interfere with function and adaptation.
Given the many negative outcomes associated with depression post injury(e.g. longer hospitalization, decreased longevity, increased rates of suicide, reduced health, daily functioning, limited community participation) it is likely best viewed as a secondary complication or sequelae rather than an adaptive process facilitating overall emotional adjustment.  Rates of suicide in the SCI population average approximately 3 to 5 times that reported in the general population.

 

Depression post SCI is a function of difficulties coping with the multiple environmental, social and health-related problems that follow.

Cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) for depression

Margaret is reluctant to start more medication as she is “not a pill person”’.  Her therapy team encourages her to give this treatment a try as it may help her participation and recovery. Margaret would like to try non-pharmacological approaches to treating her depression.  She is referred to Psychology for an assessment and possible treatment.

Understanding the effectiveness of cognitive behavioural therapy for depression post SCI.

 

18. What is cognitive behavioural therapy for depression in individuals with SCI?

The term "cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT)" is a general term for a class of psychotherapies which examines an individual’s beliefs and thought processes that underlie their mood and behaviour. The goal is to help identify and modify an individual’s cognitive distortions which lead to erroneous negative beliefs about themselves, others and the world. 

Cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) commonly employ techniques including cognitive reconstruction, behavioural activation (increasing access to pleasant activities), various forms of relaxation training, problem solving, assertiveness and coping skills training. Often it is delivered individually, but also in a group format.

 

 

19. What evidence is there for cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) for depression in individuals with SCI?

Cognitive behavioral interventions provided in a group setting appear helpful in reducing post-SCI depression and related difficulties.

Receiving CBT during the initial rehabilitation phase has been reported to reduce depressive mood, helplessness, anxiety, and is associated with fewer hospital readmissions, less drug use and greater self-reported adjustment for those patients with diagnosed depression.       

 

SCIRE found level 2 evidence to support the use of small group CBT based treatment packages to decrease depression symptoms following SCI.  However, post intervention reduction of depressive symptoms were not sustained at follow up (up to 1 year).

Pharmacotherapy for depression

 

For the past 6 weeks, Margaret has attended 1-2 appointments/week with the psychologist, who has been using cognitive behavioural approach.  Despite some initial gains, Margaret continues to experience significant depressive symptoms which are impacting upon her participation in her ongoing rehabilitation. She wants to get better, but she remains uncertain about whether she wants to go on antidepressant medications.  She meets with the physiatrist to further review the potential advantages and disadvantages of taking these medications.

Understanding pharmacological treatments for depression post SCI.

 

20. What evidence is there for pharmacotherapy in the treatment of depression following SCI?

The benefits of drug treatment for post-SCI depression are largely extrapolated from studies in non-SCI populations.

SCIRE found evidence of thebenefits of pharmacotherapy alone and in combination with individual psychotherapy in the treatment of depression in individuals with SCI is encouraging.There is level 4 evidence from two non-RCT studies indicating the effectiveness of pharmacotherapy combined with cognitive behavioral psychotherapy for treatment of depression in SCI and other chronic disabling conditions.

 

For more information, please see:Cognitive Behavioural Therapy.

Pain

Margaret is experiencing aches in her upper body and tingling pain in her lower body (below the level of her injury).  Margaret wants to know more about what is causing her pain. 

Examining the classification system of pain post SCI.

 

21.   Differentiate musculoskeletal pain from central or neuropathic pain from borderzone or segmental pain? 

  1. Musculoskeletal or mechanical pain occurs at or above the level of the lesion and is due to changes in bone, tendons or joints.
  2. Central or neuropathic pain is the most common type of pain experienced below the level of SCI and is generally characterized as a burning, aching and/or tingling sensation.
  3. Borderzone or segmental pain is experienced as a band of pain and hyperalgesia at the border zone between diminished or abnormal and preserved sensation.

Musculoskeletal or Mechanical Pain

 

Musculoskeletal or mechanical pain occurs at or above the level of the lesionand is due to changes in bone, tendons or joints.  This is referred to as nociceptive pain caused by a variety of noxious stimuli to normally innervated parts of the body. Overuse of remaining functional muscles after spinal cord injury or those recruited for unaccustomed activity may be of primary importance in some patients.

 

Central or Neuropathic Dysesthetic Pain

 

"Central" dysesthesia or "deafferentation" pain is the most common type of pain experienced below the level of SCI and is generally characterized as a burning, aching and/or tingling sensation.  In many cases this dysesthetic or deafferentation pain has defied a pathophysiological explanation.  Excluding radicular pain, all other pains of paraplegia are central or deafferentation in origin.  This pain is most often perceived in a generalized manner below the level of the lesion, often as a diffuse burning type of painBurning pain is reportedly most common with lesions at the lumbar levels.

 

One study refers to this pain as Central Dysesthetic Pain (CDP) and found dissociative sensory loss and absence of spinothalamic-anterolateral functions, with varying degrees of dorsal column function preservation present almost exclusively in incomplete SCI patients.  CDP takes weeks or months to appear and is often associated with recovery of some spinal cord function.  Paradoxically CDPis often characterized by complete loss of temperature, pinprick, and pain perception below the level of the lesion.  It rarely occurs in spinal cord Injuries with complete sensory loss or loss of both sensory and motor functions below the level of the lesion. 

 

Borderzone or Segmental Pain

 

Individuals with SCI frequently experience a band of pain and hyperalgesia at the border zone between diminished or abnormal and preserved sensation.  In the more recent literature, this segmental pain is further described as occurring at or just above the level of sensory loss in the cutaneous transition zone from the area of impaired/lost sensation to areas of normal sensation, involving at least one to three dermatomes and is often associated with spontaneous painful tingling or burning sensations in the same area.   Pain can be triggered by stroking and/or touching the skin in adjacent painful dermatomesSegmental pain is generally symmetrical although a partial spinal cord injury with asymmetrical neurological involvement will produce asymmetries.  This pain has also been described as "neuropathic at level pain" 

 

 

Pharmacological treatments for pain

Margaret is in obvious pain and wants to have her pain treated.  She agrees to initiate pharmacological treatment to manage her pain.

Understanding pharmacological treatments for pain post SCI.

 

22.  List the various pharmacological agents used in the treatment of neuropathic pain pain post SCI.

  1. Anticonvulsants Medications
  2. Tricyclic Antidepressants
  3. Anaesthetic Medications

 

Margaret is diagnosed with neuropathic pain and the decision is made to start her on an anticonvulsant, gabapentin.

Examining the use of anticonvulsants for SCI pain.

 

23.  What is the evidence for the use of anticonvulsants in SCI pain? 

  1. Gabapentin and pregabalin improve neuropathic pain post SCI.
  2. Lamotrigine may improve neuropathic pain in incomplete spinal cord injury

Anticonvulsant medications are often utilized in treating neuropathic or deafferentation pain following SCI based on the theory that these drugs alter sodium conduction in uncontrolled hyperactive neurons (“convulsive environment”) in the spinal cord.

 

Gabapentin and pregabalin have been recommended as first line treatments for neuropathic pain in Canadian and international guidelines. The mechanism of action for Pregabalin and Gabapentin is through binding the alpha 2 delta receptors in the central nervous system. These receptors are present on the presynaptic nerve terminals. When bound by gabapentin or pregabalin they decrease the influx of calcium into the presynaptic terminal thereby decreasing the release of excitatory neurotransmitters. Gabapentin and pregabalin appear to potentiate GABA effects centrally through enhancement of GABA synthesis and release.  Pregabalin is an analogue of the neurotransmitter gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA) with demonstrated analgesic, anxiolytic, and anticonvulsant activity. 

 

SCIRE found level 1 evidence that the Gabapentin and pregabalin improve neuropathic pain post SCI.  Gabapentin is more effective when SCI pain is less than 6 months duration when compared with pain of longer than 6 months (Level 4).

 

For more information, please see: Anticonvulsants.

 

Tricyclic antidepressant drugs are thought to modulate pain by inhibiting the uptake of norepinephrine and serotonin in the CNS.  Tricyclic antidepressants exert an analgesic effect by making more serotonin available in the CNS, thereby potentiating the inhibitory action of the dorsal horn of the spinal cord.  Unfortunately, these medications are often sedating and produce a variety of anticholinergic side effects.

 


Margaret is still feeling intense tingling pain.  You suggest treatment with Lidocaine through a subarachnoid lumber catheter.

Examining the use of anaesthetic medications for pain post SCI.

 

24.   What is the evidence for the use of injected anaesthetics for post-SCI pain?

Lidocaine treatment through a subarachnoid lumbar catheter and intravenous Ketamine improve post-SCI pain short term.

Anaesthetic medication such as lidocaine and ketamine are sodium channel blockers and can be delivered by a number of routes.  Given the severity of post-SCI pain, treatments such as lumbar epidural and subarachnoid infusions or anaesthetics are sometimes tried.   Ketamine is a noncompetitive N-methyl-D-Aspartate (NMDA) receptor antagonist can be administered epidurally and intrathecally (and orally) to treat neuropathic pain syndromes.

 

SCIRE found level 1 evidence that Lidocaine delivered through a subarachnoid lumbar catheter provides short-term relief of pain greater than placebo. 

 

For more information, please see: Anesthetic Treatment.

 

For more information, please see: Pharmacological Management.

 

Surgical interventions for pain

Margaret continues to suffer from severe pain despite a number of pharmacological treatments.  She is desperate and states “just cut the nerves”.  Her sister, the nurse, has been on the internet and has found a few testimonials of SCI patients whose pain was helped substantially after a surgical procedure.  Both Margaret and her sister want to know if surgery would be an option.

Examining surgical interventions for post SCI pain.

 

25.   List the various surgical interventions available for the treatment of post-SCI pain. 

  1. Spinal Cord Stimulation
  2. Destructive Neurosurgical Procedures
  3. Dorsal Rhizotomy
  4. Sympathectomy
  5. Lateral Spinothalamic Tractotomy
  6. Spinal Cordotomy

Table 2. Surgical Interventions for Post-SCI Pain

 

Treatment

Description/ Evidence

Spinal Cord Stimulation

 

Spinal cord stimulation has been used to treat intractable pain and may improve post-SCI pain. The procedure is both expensive and invasive.  Epidural electrodes are inserted percutaneously over the posterior columns of the spinal cord to allow for spinal cord stimulation.  During spinal cord stimulation, 22 patients reported parasthesias overlapping the painful area.  9 patients reported 50% pain relief and 3 patients experienced no pain relief (see Figure 4a).

 

Destructive Neurosurgical Procedures

Destructive neurosurgical procedures work best on segmental and central dysesthetic pain (Nashold, 1991).  Nashold (1991) notes that surgery for pain is best done earlier than later. The Dorsal Root Entry Zone (DREZ) procedure is reportedly the most successful procedure at the present time (Nashold 1991); however, in many cases pain is either unresponsive or returns (see Figure 4b). 

 

Dorsal Rhizotomy

Dorsal rhizotomy is a procedure where the sensory roots are divided either intradurally or extradurally.  According to Nashold (1991) a single one or two level root rhizotomy may be appropriate when the pain is localized as in those patients with paraparesis and single root pain.  Moreover, Nashold (1991) reported the Dorsal Root Entry Zone (DREZ) procedure was more likely to be successful in these patients (see Figure 4c).

 

Sympathectomy

 

Sympathectomy is not recommended for pain following SCI (Nashold 1991).  As mentioned previously, sympathetic blockade and sympathectomy have reportedly failed to relieve the central pain of SCI (White 1969; Melzack 1978; Friedman 1986) (see Figure 4d).

 

Lateral Spinothalamic Tractotomy

 

Hazouri and Mueller (1950) described three selected cases of patients with intractable root pain, subsequent to severe trauma to the cauda equina which resulted in paraplegia (L2-4 lesions).  All three patients demonstrated a distinct increase in the threshold for perception of pain and "an even more remarkable increase in the threshold for reaction to pain."  Lateral spinothalamic tractotomy in all three of these patients resulted in complete relief from pain.  Threshold studies subsequent to the tractotomy "revealed a striking return of perception and reaction thresholds to a normal range."

 

Spinal Cordotomy

 

This procedure can be performed openly or percutaneously.  Anterior spinothalamic tracts subserving pain and temperature function are sectioned, often requiring a bilateral approach.  Spinal cordotomy is an option but is rarely employed and there is little evidence that it works.

 

 

 

For more information, please see: Surgical Interventions.

 

Figure 8a. Surgical intervention available for the treatment of post-SCI pain - Spinal Cord Stimulation


 

Figure 8b. Surgical intervention available for the treatment of post-SCI pain - Destructive Neurosurgical Procedures.

 

 

Figure 8c. Surgical interventions available for the treatment of post-SCI pain - Dorsal Rhizotomy

 


 

Figure 8d. Surgical interventions available for the treatment of post-SCI pain - Sympathectomy

Quiz: Pharmophysiological effect of pharmacological HO treatments

 

How does midodrine hydrocholride effectively manage OH post SCI?

 

1. It induces more salt to be released into the bloodstream from the kidneys.

No, this is how fludrocortisone manages OH following SCI.

 

2. It activates the alpha-adrenergice receptors of teh arteriolar and venous vasulature, producing an increase in vascular tone and blood pressure.

Yes!

 

3. it interacts with alpha adrenergic receptors and has selective vasoconstrictive effects on peripheral and cranial blood vessels.

No, this is how ergotamine manages OH following SCI.